Twelve dimensions, each with a written finding and a place in the priority order. The mono line under each one is the version you can run on your own site this afternoon, and on your competitors', without contacting anybody.
-
01 The job the site is doing
What single decision the page is built around, and whether a stranger who lands there can make it without calling somebody.
Run it yourself: open your busiest landing page and name that decision in one sentence.
-
02 The inquiry path
Where an inquiry goes after it is sent, who owns it, whether it reaches the CRM, and how long it waits before a person sees it.
Run it yourself: send an inquiry through your own form and time the acknowledgement.
-
03 Speed where it is actually loaded
Measured on a mid range phone on a cellular connection, on the page a stranger lands on rather than on the homepage on office wifi.
Run it yourself: load your busiest page on a three year old phone, away from the office.
-
04 What one thumb can finish
Whether the valuable action can be completed on a phone held in one hand, including the forms, the filters, the booking and the checkout.
Run it yourself: complete your own most valuable action standing up, one handed.
-
05 Crawling and indexing
Whether the pages that matter can be reached, read and indexed, and whether the ones that should not be indexed are excluded on purpose.
Run it yourself: search your own domain with the site prefix and count what comes back.
-
06 AI crawler access
Whether the major AI crawlers are allowed to reach the site at all, which a surprising number of sites block without knowing, and whether the content is in the HTML rather than behind script.
Run it yourself: open your robots file and read it for the AI crawler names.
-
07 Whether the answers are liftable
Whether the pages answer real questions in a shape an assistant can quote cleanly, with the answer first and the depth after it.
Run it yourself: ask an assistant a question your site should answer, and read what it says instead.
-
08 Entity clarity
Whether the facts about the business are the same everywhere a machine reads them: the name, the description, the location, the services, the profiles.
Run it yourself: compare your name and description across every profile you own.
-
09 Accessibility against WCAG 2.2 AA
Keyboard, screen reader, contrast, text sizing and reduced motion, tested on the surfaces people actually use rather than asserted in a statement.
Run it yourself: complete your most valuable path with the keyboard and no mouse.
-
10 Content that earns its place
Which pages a buyer reads, which exist for the company rather than for the buyer, and which question a buyer asks that nothing on the site answers.
Run it yourself: sort your pages by entries and read the bottom ten out loud.
-
11 Measurement that agrees with itself
Whether the click, the recorded conversion and the number in the monthly report are the same event, and whether anybody could tell if they stopped being.
Run it yourself: trace one real inquiry from the click to the line in the report.
-
12 Two comparable companies
What two companies selling something similar in your market do differently, which of it matters, and which of it is fashion. Named to you in the document, never on a public page.
Run it yourself: run the eleven above on two of them and write down the three differences.
Dimension twelve is the one that changes the other eleven. A finding with no comparison is an opinion about a standard nobody agreed to, and a comparison against a company in a different market is a story. Two companies, selling something similar, to people like your customers.